What I've Learned from Watching Hundreds of Coaching Relationships

By Rebecca Marquez

I have a strange job. I don't coach anyone. I don't bill hours, I don't cross-examine anyone, and my name will never appear on a partnership track. What I do is quieter than that: I sit behind the scenes of hundreds of coaching relationships between brilliant, overworked lawyers and the coaches who help them grow. I send the calendar invites. I watch the reschedules roll in. I read the check-in notes nobody else reads twice.

And after enough time in this seat, you start to notice patterns. Not about legal strategy or billable targets, about people. About what it actually looks like when someone commits to their own growth, and what it looks like when they quietly don't.

Here's what I've learned.

The calendar doesn't lie

I can tell you, almost to a certainty, which clients will finish their program on time and which ones will still be "just about to get to it" eight months from now. I can tell you before I've read a single coaching note. I just have to look at the Calendly history.

The clients who treat their coaching sessions the way they'd treat a filing deadline, non-negotiable, blocked off, protected, are without fail, the ones who grow the most and grow the fastest. It has nothing to do with being smarter or more motivated and everything to do with consistency. Because consistency is the entire mechanism. Coaching isn't a single flash of insight; it's compound interest. You can't compound something you keep interrupting.

The clients who struggle are almost always the ones who reschedule. Not once — chronically. And here's the part that took me a while to see clearly: the reschedule emails almost never say "I don't want to do this." They say things like I'm just so slammed right now or I'm honestly running on empty or I need to push this, I just don't have anything left this week.

I believe every word of those emails. I also think they're describing a symptom, not a cause.

The thing about "I don't have time"

Here's an uncomfortable little truth I've picked up from years of watching this dynamic: the lawyers who are too depleted for their coaching call are, more often than not, the exact same people who would never in a million years cancel on a client, miss a filing, or show up unprepared to court. They will move mountains, skip lunch, and answer emails at 11pm to protect the thing they've decided matters.

Which means "I don't have time" is rarely really about time, it's about priority. That's not a criticism, it's actually touching, in a roundabout way. It shows how much care these folks pour into their work and their clients. But it also reveals something they usually can't see from inside the fog of a 60-hour week: they've quietly decided that their own growth is the most reschedulable thing on the calendar. The one meeting where the only person who suffers from a cancellation is themselves.

I've watched this pattern for long enough now to say it with confidence: it's a choice. Not a character flaw, not a moral failing, just a choice, made on autopilot, over and over, usually by people who would be horrified to realize they're making it.

The clients who get the most out of it are collaborators, not students

The best relationships I get to watch don't look like a teacher-student dynamic at all. They look like two people building something together. The client shows up with half-formed thoughts, pushes back on ideas, brings their own homework instead of waiting to be assigned it, and treats their coach less like an authority and more like a thinking partner. There's a looseness to it, an honesty. Almost like watching two good colleagues hash something out over coffee, except one of them happens to be paying for the coffee.

Compare that to the client who shows up polished, guarded, and waiting to be told what to do. Even when they're technically "compliant" (on time, doing the assignments,) something's missing. Growth, it turns out, doesn't happen to you. It happens with you.

Growth doesn't clock out at 5pm

Maybe the biggest thing I've learned, watching from this odd little vantage point, is that the coaching that actually works never stays inside the hour it's scheduled for. The clients who transform aren't the ones who show up for 50 minutes and then seal the door shut on the topic until next time. They're the ones who let it leak into the rest of their life a little, they notice the pattern from their coaching session showing up in a hard conversation with a partner, or catch themselves about to send an email in the old, exhausted version of their voice, and choose differently.

Personal growth and professional growth were never really two separate things pretending to share a Calendly link. It's one thing, one person, growing in every direction at once.

So, what have I actually learned?

Mostly this: the people who get the most out of coaching are the ones who decide quietly, repeatedly, that they're worth the same fierce protection they give everyone else. They put the recurring meeting in ink, not pencil. They show up tired sometimes and do the work anyway, the way they'd show up tired and still go to court.

I don't get a byline on anyone's transformation. I just get to watch it happen, one rescheduled-then-un-rescheduled meeting at a time. And honestly? From where I sit, it's a pretty good seat. 

---

Let's chat

Take our FREE Assessment for Lawyers